When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Heres how it works.
It’s held back by an overall cheap feeling (and looking) construction, though.
This is a visually stunning, fully metal controller which stands out from the crowd.
But if you’re someone who likes to configure their controller, you will need to look elsewhere.
So, which should you buy?
The PB Tails Crush can be picked up for $4 cheaper from thePB Tails website.
The PB Tails Metal Crush Defender will set you back$109.
Both in concept and execution, though, I appreciate how unique the design is.
The GameSir Tarantula is similarly weighty, at 11.5 ounces.
A big reason why I prefer the Tarantula is the button positioning.
The Crush Defender nailed the Xbox’s controller case shape, but the buttons felt all too close together.
No such issues with the Tarantula, though, with well placed buttons that feel great to use.
There are some minor tactile differences, however.
The Tarantula doesn’t have this issue, so I find it to be more consistent overall.
Besides from the thumbsticks, there are a few other gaming features that the Tarantula does well.
No such joys on the Crush Defender, though.
The Tarantula also comes with more buttons, with 4 bindable buttons in the middle.
Meanwhile, the PB Tails has no additional rebinds.
GameSir Tarantula Pro vs PB Tails Metal Crush Defender: Which is best?
For your first TMR controller, its a tough matchup between the two.
Stay tuned for more coverage!
More from Tom’s Guide
